Case by Dr. Chauhan Published At "Spectrum of Homeopathy" Aug 2017

“The beginning travels to the end, the end is nothing but the beginning”

-        By Dr. Dinesh Chauhan

 

Case is published at "Spectrum of Homeopathy" August 2017 (PDF)

Before life form began on earth there was nothing, no life form existed, and then the big bang happened which gave birth to the first electrons, protons, elements, the universe came into existence, cells formed and life forms started to show up in the universe, and now we know that with so much complex life forms again earth and the universe is expanding and getting more and more hot, temperature is rising and eventually the universe is going towards destruction, the scientist are now predicting that eventually the universe is going towards its end and black holes and just heat will prevail…so it is going towards completing the full circle, going towards nothingness isn’t it?

Similarly if you observe in Indian Classical Music we have the 7 “Sur” as we say it, or the 7 main notes that is “Sa, Re, Ga, Ma, Pa, Dha, Ni, Sa” so it starts from Sa and ends in Sa…

In the disease-healing phenomenon we see that it travels from centre to periphery and back to the centre.

This universality is true in all aspects of homoeopathy too, even in the understanding of the mineral kingdom. As Dr. Jan Scholten describes the periodic table in the form a spiral, where the last element of each row is placed next to the first element of the next row, hence the periodic table travels through time and end of one phase leads to the beginning of the next phase of development.

The first element of the periodic table Hydrogen and the last element of the periodic table both confluence at the same point. Similarly series 1 of the periodic table and series 7 both represent existence to destruction of universal phenomenon, whereas series 2 to series 6 represent development of individual phenomenon. In series 7 we see universal destruction. Similarly as we travel through the columns 1 through 18, they represent the thought of development of series, to developing, to developed, to maintaining to destruction of the series and then travel to the initiation of the series below completing the circle in the spiral.

In the Gold series or the row 6, as we travel across the row we see the journey of initial thought, to development, developed, maintenance, destruction of power, responsibility, autonomy, withstanding pressure.

1^st column that is Caesium there is panic at the thought of power, responsibility, in Baryta the need of support guide and philosopher for the developing the individual power, control, autonomy, in the 3^rd column at Lanthanum it is the dividing point between the sixth series and the lanthanide series. Here lanthanide is nothing but Internal, subjective, inner autonomy, power, kingdom, responsibility, control. And the gold series is External, objective, outer-power, kingdom, responsibility, control.

Hence the importance difference here is that in Lanthanides it is all about “Development of THE HIDDEN” internal power, internal responsibility, internal leadership, internal kingdom, internal autonomy, subjective inner control, developing higher sense, Samadhi, Sadhana, control of self. Whereas in the aurum line it is Development of External power, External leadership, External responsibility, External kingdom, External Autonomy

Caesium and Baryta are before the division of the row into lanthanum, and hence they have issues related to internal and external power, leadership, and responsibility

As lanthanum is at the cross roads of Lanthanides and Aurum line, in the 3^rd column it represents the confusion between the internal and external autonomy. “Confusion, as to which kind of power or leadership I need/ lack”

Similarly the whole journey of lanthanide start from confusion of inner or subjective autonomy, control, power and external Power, autonomy, control to development to developed to maintenance to gradual destruction to complete destruction.

As we move further in the Gold series or the Aurum line we see that from column 4^th (Hafnium) to 5^th (Tantalum) there is development with doubt about themselves, and 6 to 9 column (Tungsten to Iridium) represents development with surety, column 10 (Platina) is the top of the process, and 11^th and 12^th (Aurum and Mercury) are the maintaining the development to prevent the position, 13^th (Thallium) represents the beginning of destruction, 14^th (Plumbum) losing but exhaustion in holding on, 15^th (Bismuth) is lost but perseverance to save whatever is left, 16^th (Polonium) is lost all power and 17^th (Astatine) my fellow who were with me are responsible for the destruction, and column 18^th (Radon) represents the neutrality/or feeling of completion within, it is the end of power line and beginning of the actinide series of universal destruction.

Below here is an illustration of a case, step by step going through Passive, Active and Active-active case witnessing process

(NOTE: The case has been edited for brevity. Peculiar sentences are highlighted in italics, bold. My explanations, observations and notes are in plain brackets ( ), underlined or are mentioned in points. D, P, stands for Doctor and Patient respectively. Follow ups have been summarized at the end of the case. Also the sentences are kept how the patient has expressed them in his own language and flow)

 

Passive case witnessing process

D:      Yes just feel free, we have lots of time, just - express the way you want              

P:      I have written some notes so I’ll just give you! I’ll start with telling about myself. I am XYZ, 52 yrs. of age I was born in Indore which is in M.P. I am a mechanical engineer by profession with MBA and ICWA and I have been serving for the last 30Yrs in automobile companies. Here in Mumbai I am heading a company actually sitting in Mumbai        for last 1 11/2 yrs.

 Throughout my career of 30 years my job has been traveling, it has been very how I say very high pressure kind of job, but because of my nature I get pretty outgoing, and lot of chitchatting and laughing I can never feel having any kind of pressure there…

         Now on my illnesses when I was a kid, just a kid of about 3-4 years, my parent’s told me that I hold a problem with my nose hair. They will bleed heavily and it would so happen that if I run my heart beat’s faster, there was a spot on my nose and it use to start bleeding 7-8 time’s I was cauterized subsequently the doctor’s decided to operate. I was taken to homeopathic doctor in Jabalpur. After the entire history he gave medication, after 2 days it had stopped, I never had nosebleed. Many years later after 15-20 years later this gentleman was 95, he wrote to my father saying that my constitutional medicine was mercury.

         My problem today is essentially related to stomach, but there are times when I get so much of gas that stomach distends to as much as inch, inch and a half and I can feel it from the belt. So essence of what my issues are, I am extremely hypochondriac, there’s a constant fear , you are never at ease, there’s a fear. [H.G] (fist) something is wrong with me. You go for a test my frequency for checking, I do twice a year with pathological as well as you know other laboratories.

 There’s an urge to constantly need of a company. So you know particularly moving out it becomes a big problem because Anxiety is there. Unable to Enjoy, always over held by fear. Stomach I told you, it tends to distend up to about 2-2 1/2 inches. There was in the last couple of month’s back I had an issue where was feeling as if I had a digestion Issue, I would feel like it was overfull, I would feel if I burp out everything will be normal.

P:      I have a tendency to put back my ego and accommodate others. Off late that is the last 3 – 4 months office work also has been, you know it’s not giving you lot of kick and joy (H.G) (FIST) may be because of that I may be feeling bit irritated on small provocation and staff like that which is unlike me. Where I am the person who goes all out and accommodate people and generally make friends.

D:      What else! You are doing it very well you know, These is helping me to understand, whatever you speak will help me. See basically I am trying to understand you as a person, the way you think, way you sense, way you perceive your illness and yourself and whole world and more and more I find that connection it will be easy for me to find your constitution.

P:      I weigh pros and cons and analysis of the whole particular situation by and large on any issue but most of my decisions are taken on gut feeling. It is the first decision which normally becomes the last Decision that kind of thing which happens here and as a result of that my decisions comes out very fast. Believe me in my profession there are decisions which are required to be taken, which cost the company in crores and everything, touch wood till now most of the decisions I have taken turned out to be correct

P:      You know friendship and things like that when we do you are able to distribute it. But as you keep growing or climbing to the top probably you start feeling more and more alone because there are not much people to share your thought.

Relationships I would say I tend to follow up lot on relationships, that basic requirements for family structure I follow.

P:      Well as a person, I love sports, I love Music and I love to make friends and love to move around and I generally love to be in groups, I hate being spotlighted out, I mean I want to be part of crowd not the centre of the crowd

P:      Then as a person I don’t have tendency of [H.G tight fist.] vengeance. There are times when you get you know worked out and definitely you want to bash up a person given an opportunity. There are times when you get that opportunity, where guy looks at you and you look at him and ‘let him go’ that kind of attitude is there. So you know there is a tendency so forgive everybody that approach or attitude is there as far as I am concerned. So you this power [H.G .fist tight] to take him or throw him out in which case we say him forgive you can come back

{Again came the denial with strong determination that he never misuses his power with appropriate hand gesture came up}

P:      I believe it also that there’s nothing which I cannot do, I can do anything. I am not scared of picking up the broom and brushing up the floor; that is the approach, that is the attitude and few principles I follow 12 principles of Colin Powel and I felt that those principles fit very well as far as I am concerned.

1) Fancy title, fancy names come next to nothing. It is the people that actually count’s as far as organization is concerned. That is one.

2) 2^nd principle is the day the people staff bringing the problem’s to you, it is failure of your leadership either they have stopped having faith in you or they just don’t bother both of them are you know these. Then the other one is the soldier in front is always right unless proved otherwise….

P:      I am particular to see that I don’t break any rule whether it is travel rule, whether it is voucher signing rule whatever. But I don’t mind if few of my colleagues or my subordinates they break it, I mean I am trying to paint my personality

P:      I’ll always drink refrigerator water, I could rather prefer spicy. I love only homemade butter.

P:      I don’t get the feeling of being old. Everybody would like to retain you know called young person or things like that. My people here in office they don’t believe my true age if I tell them.

Active case witnessing process

D:      What else about your personality, just to understand you! See I understood whatever you spoke, any other thing or out of this entire thing what do you think the salient feature of your personality.

P:      I am more concerned about my image, that what I draw from somebody. I will go all out of way to see my image is intact . Second thing there have been pressures at home and pressure continuesI am not talking about immediate family but extended family which is my uncles and aunts and as a person who is reliable, person who is good and a person who is duty bound and what I mean by duty bound is that he is nice guy, he is taking care of his so and so. There were times where I didn’t agree to it, but no dad said we have to do it, so let’s do it, I do have that image with family but I am saying I will go all out or walk that extra miles to see that image is retained.    

D:      I didn’t understand! Just be with it, I am just trying to understand it.     

P:      What I am trying to tell you is there could be issues which I don’t agree to or given a choice I would not do them, but then protocol or this thing demands that if I have to retain my image as a person who is within the family, that he is a person who is good, who will do this, he will follow everything and he is a family man types, then I am obliged to do it and I will do it. So I choose the other course rather than fixed to my ideas that this is correct or incorrect.

D:      So what is that feeling that image is retained, you want your image as duty bound or something like that just to understand?

P:      What I mean here is not only at home even at office, if my image in my office is of a person who is an elderly person or he is a young guy who can give you right advice. So I will ensure that I will retain that image even if at times I have to go against few of my own principles {Generalizes the image part in work area also}

P:      For E.g. assume that in my company we have competitors in Mahindra so I have a lot of friends in Mahindra. So that friends in Mahindra passes me some information now it is known to everybody that this information remains between two of us and normally it is never put under this thing because otherwise that fellow gets compromised (GIVES US DIFFERENT EXAMPLES)

I am the CEO of the Mini Truck plant. There is a HCV truck which is to be handled by chairman himself. So there are times when he comes to me, XYZ why don’t you sort it out for me, I said ok. At the cost of my time here to retain that image, at cost of certain important function where may be I have to lead the press or things like that, I just forget this I do this job. It takes me 8,10hrs 12hrs 3days 10days. I have to camp somewhere I do that. I have done so many contracts for them out of way because of these. You know I am retaining that image {HAND GESTURE SHOWING THE TOP RETAINING POSITION} there is an aspiration you are climbing to that particular place now you can’t let it go… (Same hand gesture, ALLIGNMENT OF VERBAL AND NON-VERBAL LANGUAGE)

{Here we start observing that appropriate hand gestures have started coming out and patients’ body language have completely changed and patient has started connecting image in every part of life. Saying I have reached to particular position now I can’t let it go at any cost and I will retain that image at any cost.}

P:      In my school days I’ll give you small E.g. In my school days I was a Red liner, I have to make a first division, so in the ninth standard I got a first division 61%, he said, “he said looking at what you are now the day you got the first division you were not going to let it go. Now you are going to hang yourself upside down, to see that  you retain your first division position, (SAME HAND GESTURE OF TOP RETANING POSITION) because otherwise people would think as you see it, that this was a fluke. You know you got to prove yourself once, now you have to retain and keep proving it all over again and that is what exactly has happened after those years, I have kept awake, whatever I did was to see that my position was maintained, (HG) there was always a first division, this is what I would call it, I don’t know what pressure it is. There is a pressure on you to keep performing to retain that particular position that you have taken up as if you have been viewed here (SAME HAND GESTURE. (Connect the pressure of passive case taking)

P:      Another thing which probably forgot is I am ambitious but I would rather not employ on that unfair means to fulfill my ambition. I would rather not step on somebody’s stomach to prove that is one thing. (Here he is denying of unfair means so we make note of it)

Here the patient connects childhood with the image part and even with the pressure which came up in passive case witnessing process. We also observed that whenever the patient speaks of the top position or retaining, same hand gesture was coming. This was a confirmed clue that we will soon be active-active since patient has connected every part of life with image and pressure which was there in passive case witnessing process.

Active-active case witnessing process to confirm the pattern

D:      So what I have understood about you is that retains that image and retains that position, at any coast that’s the do!

P:      absolutely yes I would rather retain my position and move up the way wanted at any cost but again there is one small rider that is. There is a limit to which I would go. I would not step on the people, I would not resort to anything unethical means to achieve that. I mean unfair advantage. I will not take is what I am trying to say, but otherwise I am ambitious and I am at it. As I have earlier mentioned that there is nothing which anybody else can do that I can’t do.

{Patient denies that he would rather not employ any unfair means to fulfill his ambitions nor he would do anything that is unethical and again denies that he would not step on people to achieve his goal that means he will do it and he is doing it. So to confirm it we will ask him about this denial}

Active-active with dissociation in denial way

D:      So according to you what people do to maintain the image, maintain the position?

P:      I am just getting my e.g. what I have seen people is, they not only are driven to do what I am doing ok, but at the same time they wait for opportunity where somebody may be a somebody may give that small width to that fellow so that he can pounce on that! And he becomes one upon the others. I am saying I am not doing one man ship by putting the other person down! Other’s they will try to lift them as well as put other person down.

D:      And you are successful in maintaining the image and position. Haan!

P:      Till now yes, in future I don’t know may be I have reached a point where beyond this point it is required that I cut other’s throat [AWARENESS = Whole thing which he was denying here he is accepting it.]  

D:      I didn’t understand!

P:      If that is what is required from hands on I will not do it. I mean I am very firm on what I believe. I am not trying to crave for that position at the coast of others, this is my principle I’ll follow that {Again denying which he had already accepted in PCWP}

D:      You shall follow that Haan

P:      my ambition is to sit on the top chair for whatever time. It may so happen that I may not be in the position to sit there unless I cut a few throat I’ll not do it

D:      And that’s what the Colin Powel you said the principles, each one of them one helping you to?

P:      Yes, Yes it does! I said again every position is, to maintain is one part but only up to level I mean, you don’t cross that boundary. No unethical means and no ridding on people, we don’t want to ride and take from people

D:      So if, if I want to summaries you, you know your essence few words what you will say.

P:      As a person I have been extremely outdoor kind of person, I have been very ambitious, but I have always made equations in relationships with people and long lasting relationship, in spite of having no official boss subordinate relationship know, we are still the best of friends. I have not in my past step on anybody’s toes to make my own profits or career. I am a person who loves my family, who would like to retain my image as a family person as per the norms of whatever the society has laid down.

D:      Just one more question, you keep doing these hand gestures a lot. What does this mean? Just in general or someone says this!

P:      I must do it. I have to do it. I will do it. I can do it! {HAND GESTURE THROUGHOUT} That kind of thing is this gesture is because if there is any problem; I have no control over that

D:      Just be with it, just I am trying to understand your body language also.

P:      so normally what happens in our meetings there is an issue which is been discussed there are many facts or facet’s different personalities, they come out with. One is the ego speaks plus your knowledge base plus that I am on the top of the situation. That I am in command of the situation; I think this is expressed in this way, but that is not the universal language, may be involuntarily picked up by me. In this thing but your observation is right I have this tendency of doing this, quite often. {HAND GESTURE THROUGHOUT}

D:      Just be with it, it’s helping me to understand, just “I the ego and the command of situation” just be with it.

P:      Ego and command is definitely there, but what I am trying to say is I know the subject you don’t know the subject so you leave it to me now. It is in the proper hands you let go the whole issue and be with whatever I am trying to tell you this is. I am on the top of the situation, I can control this, whole thing is undertaken control, so first forget it, relax, leave it, it will happen. {H.G of fist throughout}

P:      My body language I try not to be very forceful on others, yet I am amenable to all suggestions, at the same time I am trying to be away from it

D:      So you are like a firm. But yet

P:      Yet the Flexible man. As I said no spotlight on you, I don’t want to be branded out as a person who is different; I don’t want to be branded out as a person who is soft.

Case ends

UNDERSTANDING OF THE WHOLE CASE

 In the Passive case witnessing OUT OF PLACE, OUT OF ORDER expressions of the patient

·       I’ll start with myself

·       High pressure

·       Constitutional medicine mercury

·       Extremely hypochondriac

·       Anxiety and constant fear

·       Put back my ego and accommodate others

·       Generally my 1^st decision becomes the last decision

·       As you go on top you become alone

·       Basic requirement of family structure you follow

·       Hates to be spotlighted

·       Likes to be part of the crowd

·       No tendency of vengeance

·       Power to throw or keep

·       12 Colin Powel principles which I follow

·       Failure of leadership

·       Soldier in front always right

·       Rare hierarchy

·       Loves travelling extensively

·       Nothing which I can’t do

·       Any challenging job I can do

·       Don’t break any rules

·       Trying to paint my personality

·       Feeling of old never comes

LEVEL OF EXPERIENCE:  DELUSION

TOUCH: GOOD QUALITES WITH HIMSELF, BAD QUALITES DENIAL

HAND GESTURE CAME UP BUT NOT APPROPRIATE

In the Active case witnessing process

·             The focus was not so clear although pressure came up in 2-3 areas and even H.G came up in some areas but they were not very appropriate so we asked him the salient features of his personality in general

·             Here we see new things coming up in a different area, which are very peculiar, patient says “I am more concerned about my image and I will go out of my way or walk that extra miles to see that my image is retained plus I am a person who is reliable who is duty bound” which was completely out of place so we explore these area further

·             Now gradually the patient starts connecting the image part in his family life also, and he says that there is a pressure to maintain an image in family and for that if he has to do anything for e.g.: paying RS20000 extra he will do that, so that his image is retained. Then patient himself says why only in family even in office I will see to it that my image is retained at any cost.

·             On asking him about this image and retaining it, he says that even if he has to go against his own principles to retain image he would, he also said he would rather not employ unfair means to fulfill my ambition. Here the same point which he has denied in passive part comes up

·             Now the patient jumps into new area of childhood and we see that patient connects image part with childhood and says he has to prove himself again and again to maintain that position. “There’s is a pressure on you to keep performing. Pressure to retain that position” We also observed that whenever the patient speaks of the top position or retaining same hand gesture was coming. This was a confirmed clue that we will soon be active-active since patient has connected every part of life with image and pressure which was also there in passive case witnessing process. And also appropriate hand gestures start coming up

This confirms the focus of the case: pressure of maintaining image was the centre of the patient so we become active-active to confirm it

   In the Active-active case witnessing process

·             On asking him about the focus, patient denies that he would rather not employ any unfair means to fulfill his ambitions nor he would do anything that is unethical and again denies that he would not step on people to achieve his goal that means he will do it and he is doing it. So to confirm it we will ask him about this denial. Patient was trying to prove his denial by giving his example how he helped one of his colleague by allowing him to lead in one of the project and he himself assisted him in that project  so to make him aware of his denial we dissociate him

·             The patient projected his denial on other people by saying they become ruthless and they wait for the opportunity to pounce on others

·             On asking him “And you are successful in maintaining the image and position?” to which he replies “Till now yes, in future I don’t know may be I have reached a point where beyond this point it is required that I cut other’s throat.”

·             Here we get a fair idea of the remedy, so we ask him questions for confirmation by asking him about Colin Powel’s principle, then ask him to summarize everything, and ask him about the hand gesture which became appropriate in active-active

·             We see all connect to with image, top position, retaining, maintaining the top position, patient adds one more point of ego with it saying I am on the top, I am in the command of situation you don’t know the subject so leave it to me}

Hence centre of the case is: maintaining Image, retaining top position, pressure and hand gesture

KINGDOM: MINERAL (Patient’s body language and appropriate hand gesture pointing towards mineral. Patient’s words such as family structure, top position, duty bound I and the ego, self-esteem all this confirmed mineral)           

SERIES/ROW: 7^th row and 6^th row

The way the patient started the case with myself then paint my picture, then in active-active, the whole phenomena of image was connected by patient to every part of his life therefore 3^rd series, with this patient has super blotted sense of I and patient himself says I, myself and the ego speaks in active-active case witnessing process which is the core of the Sulphur

But with all this he also says about the top position of organization, Power, Decision taking, Self-esteem, Duty bound. This speaks about 6th series. So both 3^rd and 6^th row are coming up.

COLUMN

Maintain self-esteem, maintaining top position, Retaining top position, Speaks about 11^th and 12^th column.

11^th column: Maintain with dignity, just beginning of maintenance, it is about maintaining with grace, they know that they can maintain it. Like Roger Federer, cricketer Sachin Tendulkar

12^th column: Maintaining at any cost do anything, but maintain that position, whether to pounce on other, cut others throat, take vengeances, anyhow and at any cost, I have to maintain it. So it was confirmed that patient belonged to 12^th column of 6^th row. That is MERCURY.

 Therefore we gave Merc-sulph since it covered image, ego and maintain at any cost.

Confirmation Symptoms of Merc-Sulph

·       Travelling desire,

·       Craving for cold things

·       Craving bread and butter

·       Fond of liquor

·       He received mercury in childhood 

Follow ups

1^st Follow-up (after 3 weeks)

·             First 3-4 days I was feeling miserable constant fear was there and I was in hill station in Japan with my daughter but I was not able to enjoy in the sense that always that nagging fear was there. Something is wrong with me, blotting was there, and that blotting yes I want to tell you have subsided to a great extent. My belt as I said after having so much food also I don’t have to loose belt 2 notches or 3 notches which I earlier did. \

·             Apprehension that was always there, that has come down to a great extent, but the emotional you know, you see a movie you get touched you get tears in your eyes! Emotional thing is still there, and that is not come down!

2^nd Follow-up (after 2 months)

P:      Am fine! There was symptom of heaviness; uneasiness in stomach that is practically gone. Old symptom’s which were there, they have started, I had a frozen shoulder about 4 years back I don’t have a frozen shoulder now, but I feel a little like it has started to come. My sleep patterns have improved, I am sleeping soundly. I am more focused I would say not wavering. I am trying to drink more of room temperature water

D:      What other changes in you as a person?

P:      Irritation has decreased I used to get irritated. I am not snappy; I am more approachable and amiable. And there was this idea of earlier lot of decision on gut feeling, now the gut feeling is there, but I also think over it in a sense that I am able to concentrate, I am able to retaliate the pro’s and con’s and then come to  some kind decision.

D:      How is that whole feeling of maintaining the position, pressure of maintaining the position?

P:      One thing I was looking at my current profile and current job that I have to get to top somewhere. See earlier it was focused, so whatever coming in between either it got demolished or I got demolished that was the approach and that precipitated lot of anger inside! Now not looking at it with that smaller perspective, looking at larger perspective is there any other way through which I can reach there, I would say, broadening of perspective. I am not compromising my target per say but I am trying to refined the route in such a way that in its destructive way.

D:      So do you think you have started knowing you real being inside haan.

P:      books that I used to read were more of guns and unknown identity and those, but now I read stuff like with more human touch kind of thing. Compassion is the one word I could say may be I feel            much more compassionate towards other people than earlier.

3^rd follow up (after 3 months)

D:      Since the last time that we met but since the beginning, since the first time we met just to recapitulate overall how are you in every aspect, you remember what you said?

P:      Much Better! Much Better! See I had a stomach issue, stomach issue is gone. I was feeling of great uneasiness because I believe that stomach would distend to whatever that has improved greatly, I was sentimental, emotional I was driven to tears may be on small things! I have improved overall to extent about 80% still those. I find huge improvement since the last time.

D:      How is all mental feeling which you describe to me, about maintaining and you remember?

P:      This punch that drive is still there but expression is tamed off to some extent, I mean earlier it used to be visible with somehow. Earlier I use to be aggressive in   meetings; I use to be vocal in my meetings. Now off late I have been more diplomatic kind off !I mean I am not losing cool over things and even if I do I am not conveying out to you that there is there some problem or something like that.

Follow up after 6 months

D:      So what this treatment has made a difference in you as a person.

P:      One the fear which I had within myself that something is wrong with the system, I find that fears to great extent have vanished and the anxiety which was there inside, there is no pain it has reduced drastically!

Secondly thing is if I was looking at particular situation or object with a perspective, I was not in a position to look at it with larger perspective, e.g. suppose I am   doing this in this my profit there but what happens to the other person! So you are not more of a single player, you are more of a how do I say team, team player no, you are more of a co-existence according to me.

P:      self-confidence has increase thirdly thing survival in group, I would in say in group in society, it is not alone me it is other’s also, these to a great extent has helped me, the way I looked at it.

D:      What do you mean by larger perspective?

P:      Sir before I use to tell you I could tell you my thought I have to do it, I ‘THE BIG’ ‘I’ was there to a great extent, I think the only thing is when you are looking at anything with an ‘I’, now I am able to look at other story also

P:      So what is good thing in these is, in our office cut throat is going on in every day to day affair. Now you have got many more friends you know, you are able to co-exist with lot of people. Lot of changes are there within I would say, if you ask me medically I cannot pinpoint it, these is how things are personally.

D:      So when you say larger perspective, what?

P:      I have become much more aware of what I was. Earlier that motive was narrow minded or selfish. It was self-centered kind. My work will be done and it will not have bad effect on other person, this is what I am trying to convey.

D:      What do you mean by ‘I’ has softened?

P:      I am working for many years on different ranks so ‘I’ becomes larger than you, the ego part I would say, ‘I’ is too big and what happens is that ‘I’ when starts getting challenged by people, then you start getting hate from inside, worry starts coming up, anxiety starts, I mean if you are able to communicate, convey it properly, work is also done.

Follow up after 8 months

D:      You said last time, I am watching as a third observer.

P:      Third Observer, sometime I laugh that you are reacting in such a way. Its great earlier you use to get involved, you get angry, further anger increases, more it increases. Now a days it doesn’t happen you are relaxed, automatically you are away, there are two people discussing and it’s fun you are able to laugh at yourself then. In last 4-5 months, I have not lost my temper at all

I am able to grasp myself that I am one personality, I am discussing something but I am in a position to get aloof from whole system, I am able to watch as a neutral person, the dialogue which is            going on between two person, I am able to analyze it at real time at equal as an independent personality.

I am not been prejudice towards me O.K, I am able to look at it as a third umpire or neutral person and in that I am able to find out in me, I shouldn’t have done this and that comes out     very effectively there itself correction is done, because I myself is there, I am able to, you know weigh your consequences. So no anger no frustration, no anxiety, and no negativity.

Applying the universal laws we not only understand the individualistic holistic centre of the individual, but even the Materia Medica, even the universality of the periodic table, each row, column, each element in the periodic table. Universal laws help in understanding the whole and also the part, which is nothing but integrated into the whole and beautifully completes the circle of the beginning to end to beginning.

 

Biography: Dr. Dinesh Chauhan practices Classical homoeopathy in Mumbai, India. Case Witnessing Process is a scientific and human-centric case taking approach developed by him over a decade of research and seeing patient after patient at Swasthya Homeopathic Healing. Distinguished as a lecturer in many countries, he has the ability to captivate listener’s attention as he masterfully makes homoeopathic theory come to life. He heads the non-profit ABJF foundation with his wife Dr. Urvi Chauhan where Indian Homoeopaths are taught free. He is the author of the books A Journey into the Human Core; A Wander with a Little Wonder - Child centric Case witnessing, and The Scientifically Intuitive Case Witnessing Process – A Journey of Three Steps.

Website: www.homeohome.com , www.casewitnessing.com

Email: This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it. , This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.

 

 

 

 

“The beginning travels to the end, the end is nothing but the beginning”

-        By Dr. Dinesh Chauhan

Before life form began on earth there was nothing, no life form existed, and then the big bang happened which gave birth to the first electrons, protons, elements, the universe came into existence, cells formed and life forms started to show up in the universe, and now we know that with so much complex life forms again earth and the universe is expanding and getting more and more hot, temperature is rising and eventually the universe is going towards destruction, the scientist are now predicting that eventually the universe is going towards its end and black holes and just heat will prevail…so it is going towards completing the full circle, going towards nothingness isn’t it?

Similarly if you observe in Indian Classical Music we have the 7 “Sur” as we say it, or the 7 main notes that is “Sa, Re, Ga, Ma, Pa, Dha, Ni, Sa” so it starts from Sa and ends in Sa…

In the disease-healing phenomenon we see that it travels from centre to periphery and back to the centre.

This universality is true in all aspects of homoeopathy too, even in the understanding of the mineral kingdom. As Dr. Jan Scholten describes the periodic table in the form a spiral, where the last element of each row is placed next to the first element of the next row, hence the periodic table travels through time and end of one phase leads to the beginning of the next phase of development.

The first element of the periodic table Hydrogen and the last element of the periodic table both confluence at the same point. Similarly series 1 of the periodic table and series 7 both represent existence to destruction of universal phenomenon, whereas series 2 to series 6 represent development of individual phenomenon. In series 7 we see universal destruction. Similarly as we travel through the columns 1 through 18, they represent the thought of development of series, to developing, to developed, to maintaining to destruction of the series and then travel to the initiation of the series below completing the circle in the spiral.

In the Gold series or the row 6, as we travel across the row we see the journey of initial thought, to development, developed, maintenance, destruction of power, responsibility, autonomy, withstanding pressure.

1^st column that is Caesium there is panic at the thought of power, responsibility, in Baryta the need of support guide and philosopher for the developing the individual power, control, autonomy, in the 3^rd column at Lanthanum it is the dividing point between the sixth series and the lanthanide series. Here lanthanide is nothing but Internal, subjective, inner autonomy, power, kingdom, responsibility, control. And the gold series is External, objective, outer-power, kingdom, responsibility, control.

Hence the importance difference here is that in Lanthanides it is all about “Development of THE HIDDEN” internal power, internal responsibility, internal leadership, internal kingdom, internal autonomy, subjective inner control, developing higher sense, Samadhi, Sadhana, control of self. Whereas in the aurum line it is Development of External power, External leadership, External responsibility, External kingdom, External Autonomy

Caesium and Baryta are before the division of the row into lanthanum, and hence they have issues related to internal and external power, leadership, and responsibility

As lanthanum is at the cross roads of Lanthanides and Aurum line, in the 3^rd column it represents the confusion between the internal and external autonomy. “Confusion, as to which kind of power or leadership I need/ lack”

Similarly the whole journey of lanthanide start from confusion of inner or subjective autonomy, control, power and external Power, autonomy, control to development to developed to maintenance to gradual destruction to complete destruction.

As we move further in the Gold series or the Aurum line we see that from column 4^th (Hafnium) to 5^th (Tantalum) there is development with doubt about themselves, and 6 to 9 column (Tungsten to Iridium) represents development with surety, column 10 (Platina) is the top of the process, and 11^th and 12^th (Aurum and Mercury) are the maintaining the development to prevent the position, 13^th (Thallium) represents the beginning of destruction, 14^th (Plumbum) losing but exhaustion in holding on, 15^th (Bismuth) is lost but perseverance to save whatever is left, 16^th (Polonium) is lost all power and 17^th (Astatine) my fellow who were with me are responsible for the destruction, and column 18^th (Radon) represents the neutrality/or feeling of completion within, it is the end of power line and beginning of the actinide series of universal destruction.

Below here is an illustration of a case, step by step going through Passive, Active and Active-active case witnessing process

(NOTE: The case has been edited for brevity. Peculiar sentences are highlighted in italics, bold. My explanations, observations and notes are in plain brackets ( ), underlined or are mentioned in points. D, P, stands for Doctor and Patient respectively. Follow ups have been summarized at the end of the case. Also the sentences are kept how the patient has expressed them in his own language and flow)

 

Passive case witnessing process

D:      Yes just feel free, we have lots of time, just - express the way you want              

P:      I have written some notes so I’ll just give you! I’ll start with telling about myself. I am XYZ, 52 yrs. of age I was born in Indore which is in M.P. I am a mechanical engineer by profession with MBA and ICWA and I have been serving for the last 30Yrs in automobile companies. Here in Mumbai I am heading a company actually sitting in Mumbai        for last 1 11/2 yrs.

Throughout my career of 30 years my job has been traveling, it has been very how I say very high pressure kind of job, but because of my nature I get pretty outgoing, and lot of chitchatting and laughing I can never feel having any kind of pressure there…

         Now on my illnesses when I was a kid, just a kid of about 3-4 years, my parent’s told me that I hold a problem with my nose hair. They will bleed heavily and it would so happen that if I run my heart beat’s faster, there was a spot on my nose and it use to start bleeding 7-8 time’s I was cauterized subsequently the doctor’s decided to operate. I was taken to homeopathic doctor in Jabalpur. After the entire history he gave medication, after 2 days it had stopped, I never had nosebleed. Many years later after 15-20 years later this gentleman was 95, he wrote to my father saying that my constitutional medicine was mercury.

         My problem today is essentially related to stomach, but there are times when I get so much of gas that stomach distends to as much as inch, inch and a half and I can feel it from the belt. So essence of what my issues are, I am extremely hypochondriac, there’s a constant fear, you are never at ease, there’s a fear. [H.G] (fist) something is wrong with me. You go for a test my frequency for checking, I do twice a year with pathological as well as you know other laboratories.

There’s an urge to constantly need of a company. So you know particularly moving out it becomes a big problem because Anxiety is there. Unable to Enjoy, always over held by fear. Stomach I told you, it tends to distend up to about 2-2 1/2 inches. There was in the last couple of month’s back I had an issue where was feeling as if I had a digestion Issue, I would feel like it was overfull, I would feel if I burp out everything will be normal.

P:      I have a tendency to put back my ego and accommodate others. Off late that is the last 3 – 4 months office work also has been, you know it’s not giving you lot of kick and joy (H.G) (FIST) may be because of that I may be feeling bit irritated on small provocation and staff like that which is unlike me. Where I am the person who goes all out and accommodate people and generally make friends.

D:      What else! You are doing it very well you know, These is helping me to understand, whatever you speak will help me. See basically I am trying to understand you as a person, the way you think, way you sense, way you perceive your illness and yourself and whole world and more and more I find that connection it will be easy for me to find your constitution.

P:      I weigh pros and cons and analysis of the whole particular situation by and large on any issue but most of my decisions are taken on gut feeling. It is the first decision which normally becomes the last Decision that kind of thing which happens here and as a result of that my decisions comes out very fast. Believe me in my profession there are decisions which are required to be taken, which cost the company in crores and everything, touch wood till now most of the decisions I have taken turned out to be correct

P:      You know friendship and things like that when we do you are able to distribute it. But as you keep growing or climbing to the top probably you start feeling more and more alone because there are not much people to share your thought.

Relationships I would say I tend to follow up lot on relationships, that basic requirements for family structure I follow.

P:      Well as a person, I love sports, I love Music and I love to make friends and love to move around and I generally love to be in groups, I hate being spotlighted out, I mean I want to be part of crowd not the centre of the crowd

P:      Then as a person I don’t have tendency of [H.G tight fist.] vengeance. There are times when you get you know worked out and definitely you want to bash up a person given an opportunity. There are times when you get that opportunity, where guy looks at you and you look at him and ‘let him go’ that kind of attitude is there. So you know there is a tendency so forgive everybody that approach or attitude is there as far as I am concerned. So you this power [H.G .fist tight] to take him or throw him out in which case we say him forgive you can come back

{Again came the denial with strong determination that he never misuses his power with appropriate hand gesture came up}

P:      I believe it also that there’s nothing which I cannot do, I can do anything. I am not scared of picking up the broom and brushing up the floor; that is the approach, that is the attitude and few principles I follow 12 principles of Colin Powel and I felt that those principles fit very well as far as I am concerned.

1) Fancy title, fancy names come next to nothing. It is the people that actually count’s as far as organization is concerned. That is one.

2) 2^nd principle is the day the people staff bringing the problem’s to you, it is failure of your leadership either they have stopped having faith in you or they just don’t bother both of them are you know these. Then the other one is the soldier in front is always right unless proved otherwise….

P:      I am particular to see that I don’t break any rule whether it is travel rule, whether it is voucher signing rule whatever. But I don’t mind if few of my colleagues or my subordinates they break it, I mean I am trying to paint my personality

P:      I’ll always drink refrigerator water, I could rather prefer spicy. I love only homemade butter.

P:      I don’t get the feeling of being old. Everybody would like to retain you know called young person or things like that. My people here in office they don’t believe my true age if I tell them.

Active case witnessing process

D:      What else about your personality, just to understand you! See I understood whatever you spoke, any other thing or out of this entire thing what do you think the salient feature of your personality.

P:      I am more concerned about my image, that what I draw from somebody. I will go all out of way to see my image is intact. Second thing there have been pressures at home and pressure continuesI am not talking about immediate family but extended family which is my uncles and aunts and as a person who is reliable, person who is good and a person who is duty bound and what I mean by duty bound is that he is nice guy, he is taking care of his so and so. There were times where I didn’t agree to it, but no dad said we have to do it, so let’s do it, I do have that image with family but I am saying I will go all out or walk that extra miles to see that image is retained.    

D:      I didn’t understand! Just be with it, I am just trying to understand it.     

P:      What I am trying to tell you is there could be issues which I don’t agree to or given a choice I would not do them, but then protocol or this thing demands that if I have to retain my image as a person who is within the family, that he is a person who is good, who will do this, he will follow everything and he is a family man types, then I am obliged to do it and I will do it. So I choose the other course rather than fixed to my ideas that this is correct or incorrect.

D:      So what is that feeling that image is retained, you want your image as duty bound or something like that just to understand?

P:      What I mean here is not only at home even at office, if my image in my office is of a person who is an elderly person or he is a young guy who can give you right advice. So I will ensure that I will retain that image even if at times I have to go against few of my own principles {Generalizes the image part in work area also}

P:      For E.g. assume that in my company we have competitors in Mahindra so I have a lot of friends in Mahindra. So that friends in Mahindra passes me some information now it is known to everybody that this information remains between two of us and normally it is never put under this thing because otherwise that fellow gets compromised (GIVES US DIFFERENT EXAMPLES)

I am the CEO of the Mini Truck plant. There is a HCV truck which is to be handled by chairman himself. So there are times when he comes to me, XYZ why don’t you sort it out for me, I said ok. At the cost of my time here to retain that image, at cost of certain important function where may be I have to lead the press or things like that, I just forget this I do this job. It takes me 8,10hrs 12hrs 3days 10days. I have to camp somewhere I do that. I have done so many contracts for them out of way because of these. You know I am retaining that image {HAND GESTURE SHOWING THE TOP RETAINING POSITION}there is an aspiration you are climbing to that particular place now you can’t let it go… (Same hand gesture, ALLIGNMENT OF VERBAL AND NON-VERBAL LANGUAGE)

{Here we start observing that appropriate hand gestures have started coming out and patients’ body language have completely changed and patient has started connecting image in every part of life. Saying I have reached to particular position now I can’t let it go at any cost and I will retain that image at any cost.}

P:      In my school days I’ll give you small E.g. In my school days I was a Red liner, I have to make a first division, so in the ninth standard I got a first division 61%, he said, “he said looking at what you are now the day you got the first division you were not going to let it go. Now you are going to hang yourself upside down, to see that you retain your first division position, (SAME HAND GESTURE OF TOP RETANING POSITION) because otherwise people would think as you see it, that this was a fluke. You know you got to prove yourself once, now you have to retain and keep proving it all over again and that is what exactly has happened after those years, I have kept awake, whatever I did was to see that my position was maintained, (HG) there was always a first division, this is what I would call it, I don’t know what pressure it is. There is a pressure on you to keep performing to retain that particular position that you have taken up as if you have been viewed here (SAME HAND GESTURE. (Connect the pressure of passive case taking)

P:      Another thing which probably forgot is I am ambitious but I would rather not employ on that unfair means to fulfill my ambition. I would rather not step on somebody’s stomach to prove that is one thing. (Here he is denying of unfair means so we make note of it)

Here the patient connects childhood with the image part and even with the pressure which came up in passive case witnessing process. We also observed that whenever the patient speaks of the top position or retaining, same hand gesture was coming. This was a confirmed clue that we will soon be active-active since patient has connected every part of life with image and pressure which was there in passive case witnessing process.

Active-active case witnessing process to confirm the pattern

D:      So what I have understood about you is that retains that image and retains that position, at any coast that’s the do!

P:      absolutely yes I would rather retain my position and move up the way wanted at any cost but again there is one small rider that is. There is a limit to which I would go. I would not step on the people, I would not resort to anything unethical means to achieve that. I mean unfair advantage. I will not take is what I am trying to say, but otherwise I am ambitious and I am at it. As I have earlier mentioned that there is nothing which anybody else can do that I can’t do.

{Patient denies that he would rather not employ any unfair means to fulfill his ambitions nor he would do anything that is unethical and again denies that he would not step on people to achieve his goal that means he will do it and he is doing it. So to confirm it we will ask him about this denial}

Active-active with dissociation in denial way

D:      So according to you what people do to maintain the image, maintain the position?

P:      I am just getting my e.g. what I have seen people is, they not only are driven to do what I am doing ok, but at the same time they wait for opportunity where somebody may be a somebody may give that small width to that fellow so that he can pounce on that! And he becomes one upon the others. I am saying I am not doing one man ship by putting the other person down! Other’s they will try to lift them as well as put other person down.

D:      And you are successful in maintaining the image and position. Haan!

P:      Till now yes, in future I don’t know may be I have reached a point where beyond this point it is required that I cut other’s throat [AWARENESS = Whole thing which he was denying here he is accepting it.]

D:      I didn’t understand!

P:      If that is what is required from hands on I will not do it. I mean I am very firm on what I believe. I am not trying to crave for that position at the coast of others, this is my principle I’ll follow that {Again denying which he had already accepted in PCWP}

D:      You shall follow that Haan

P:      my ambition is to sit on the top chair for whatever time. It may so happen that I may not be in the position to sit there unless I cut a few throat I’ll not do it

D:      And that’s what the Colin Powel you said the principles, each one of them one helping you to?

P:      Yes, Yes it does! I said again every position is, to maintain is one part but only up to level I mean, you don’t cross that boundary. No unethical means and no ridding on people, we don’t want to ride and take from people

D:      So if, if I want to summaries you, you know your essence few words what you will say.

P:      As a person I have been extremely outdoor kind of person, I have been very ambitious, but I have always made equations in relationships with people and long lasting relationship, in spite of having no official boss subordinate relationship know, we are still the best of friends. I have not in my past step on anybody’s toes to make my own profits or career. I am a person who loves my family, who would like to retain my image as a family person as per the norms of whatever the society has laid down.

D:      Just one more question, you keep doing these hand gestures a lot. What does this mean? Just in general or someone says this!

P:      I must do it. I have to do it. I will do it. I can do it! {HAND GESTURE THROUGHOUT} That kind of thing is this gesture is because if there is any problem; I have no control over that

D:      Just be with it, just I am trying to understand your body language also.

P:      so normally what happens in our meetings there is an issue which is been discussed there are many facts or facet’s different personalities, they come out with. One is the ego speaks plus your knowledge base plus that I am on the top of the situation. That I am in command of the situation; I think this is expressed in this way, but that is not the universal language, may be involuntarily picked up by me. In this thing but your observation is right I have this tendency of doing this, quite often. {HAND GESTURE THROUGHOUT}

D:      Just be with it, it’s helping me to understand, just “I the ego and the command of situation” just be with it.

P:      Ego and command is definitely there, but what I am trying to say is I know the subject you don’t know the subject so you leave it to me now. It is in the proper hands you let go the whole issue and be with whatever I am trying to tell you this is. I am on the top of the situation, I can control this, whole thing is undertaken control, so first forget it, relax, leave it, it will happen. {H.G of fist throughout}

P:      My body language I try not to be very forceful on others, yet I am amenable to all suggestions, at the same time I am trying to be away from it

D:      So you are like a firm. But yet

P:      Yet the Flexible man. As I said no spotlight on you, I don’t want to be branded out as a person who is different; I don’t want to be branded out as a person who is soft.

Case ends

UNDERSTANDING OF THE WHOLE CASE

In the Passive case witnessing OUT OF PLACE, OUT OF ORDER expressions of the patient

·       I’ll start with myself

·       High pressure

·       Constitutional medicine mercury

·       Extremely hypochondriac

·       Anxiety and constant fear

·       Put back my ego and accommodate others

·       Generally my 1^st decision becomes the last decision

·       As you go on top you become alone

·       Basic requirement of family structure you follow

·       Hates to be spotlighted

·       Likes to be part of the crowd

·       No tendency of vengeance

·       Power to throw or keep

·       12 Colin Powel principles which I follow

·       Failure of leadership

·       Soldier in front always right

·       Rare hierarchy

·       Loves travelling extensively

·       Nothing which I can’t do

·       Any challenging job I can do

·       Don’t break any rules

·       Trying to paint my personality

·       Feeling of old never comes

LEVEL OF EXPERIENCE:  DELUSION

TOUCH: GOOD QUALITES WITH HIMSELF, BAD QUALITES DENIAL

HAND GESTURE CAME UP BUT NOT APPROPRIATE

In the Active case witnessing process

·             The focus was not so clear although pressure came up in 2-3 areas and even H.G came up in some areas but they were not very appropriate so we asked him the salient features of his personality in general

·             Here we see new things coming up in a different area, which are very peculiar, patient says “I am more concerned about my image and I will go out of my way or walk that extra miles to see that my image is retained plus I am a person who is reliable who is duty bound” which was completely out of place so we explore these area further

·             Now gradually the patient starts connecting the image part in his family life also, and he says that there is a pressure to maintain an image in family and for that if he has to do anything for e.g.: paying RS20000 extra he will do that, so that his image is retained. Then patient himself says why only in family even in office I will see to it that my image is retained at any cost.

·             On asking him about this image and retaining it, he says that even if he has to go against his own principles to retain image he would, he also said he would rather not employ unfair means to fulfill my ambition. Here the same point which he has denied in passive part comes up

·             Now the patient jumps into new area of childhood and we see that patient connects image part with childhood and says he has to prove himself again and again to maintain that position. “There’s is a pressure on you to keep performing. Pressure to retain that position” We also observed that whenever the patient speaks of the top position or retaining same hand gesture was coming. This was a confirmed clue that we will soon be active-active since patient has connected every part of life with image and pressure which was also there in passive case witnessing process. And also appropriate hand gestures start coming up

This confirms the focus of the case: pressure of maintaining image was the centre of the patient so we become active-active to confirm it

  In the Active-active case witnessing process

·             On asking him about the focus, patient denies that he would rather not employ any unfair means to fulfill his ambitions nor he would do anything that is unethical and again denies that he would not step on people to achieve his goal that means he will do it and he is doing it. So to confirm it we will ask him about this denial. Patient was trying to prove his denial by giving his example how he helped one of his colleague by allowing him to lead in one of the project and he himself assisted him in that project  so to make him aware of his denial we dissociate him

·             The patient projected his denial on other people by saying they become ruthless and they wait for the opportunity to pounce on others

·             On asking him “And you are successful in maintaining the image and position?” to which he replies “Till now yes, in future I don’t know may be I have reached a point where beyond this point it is required that I cut other’s throat.”

·             Here we get a fair idea of the remedy, so we ask him questions for confirmation by asking him about Colin Powel’s principle, then ask him to summarize everything, and ask him about the hand gesture which became appropriate in active-active

·             We see all connect to with image, top position, retaining, maintaining the top position, patient adds one more point of ego with it saying I am on the top, I am in the command of situation you don’t know the subject so leave it to me}

Hence centre of the case is: maintaining Image, retaining top position, pressure and hand gesture

KINGDOM: MINERAL (Patient’s body language and appropriate hand gesture pointing towards mineral. Patient’s words such as family structure, top position, duty bound I and the ego, self-esteem all this confirmed mineral)           

SERIES/ROW: 7^th row and 6^th row

The way the patient started the case with myself then paint my picture, then in active-active, the whole phenomena of image was connected by patient to every part of his life therefore 3^rd series, with this patient has super blotted sense of I and patient himself says I, myself and the ego speaks in active-active case witnessing process which is the core of the Sulphur

But with all this he also says about the top position of organization, Power, Decision taking, Self-esteem, Duty bound. This speaks about 6th series. So both 3^rd and 6^th row are coming up.

COLUMN

Maintain self-esteem, maintaining top position, Retaining top position, Speaks about 11^th and 12^th column.

11^th column: Maintain with dignity, just beginning of maintenance, it is about maintaining with grace, they know that they can maintain it. Like Roger Federer, cricketer Sachin Tendulkar

12^th column: Maintaining at any cost do anything, but maintain that position, whether to pounce on other, cut others throat, take vengeances, anyhow and at any cost, I have to maintain it. So it was confirmed that patient belonged to 12^th column of 6^th row. That is MERCURY.

Therefore we gave Merc-sulph since it covered image, ego and maintain at any cost.

Confirmation Symptoms of Merc-Sulph

·       Travelling desire,

·       Craving for cold things

·       Craving bread and butter

·       Fond of liquor

·       He received mercury in childhood 

Follow ups

1^st Follow-up (after 3 weeks)

·             First 3-4 days I was feeling miserable constant fear was there and I was in hill station in Japan with my daughter but I was not able to enjoy in the sense that always that nagging fear was there. Something is wrong with me, blotting was there, and that blotting yes I want to tell you have subsided to a great extent. My belt as I said after having so much food also I don’t have to loose belt 2 notches or 3 notches which I earlier did. \

·             Apprehension that was always there, that has come down to a great extent, but the emotional you know, you see a movie you get touched you get tears in your eyes! Emotional thing is still there, and that is not come down!

2^nd Follow-up (after 2 months)

P:      Am fine! There was symptom of heaviness; uneasiness in stomach that is practically gone. Old symptom’s which were there, they have started, I had a frozen shoulder about 4 years back I don’t have a frozen shoulder now, but I feel a little like it has started to come. My sleep patterns have improved, I am sleeping soundly. I am more focused I would say not wavering. I am trying to drink more of room temperature water

D:      What other changes in you as a person?

P:      Irritation has decreased I used to get irritated. I am not snappy; I am more approachable and amiable. And there was this idea of earlier lot of decision on gut feeling, now the gut feeling is there, but I also think over it in a sense that I am able to concentrate, I am able to retaliate the pro’s and con’s and then come to  some kind decision.

D:      How is that whole feeling of maintaining the position, pressure of maintaining the position?

P:      One thing I was looking at my current profile and current job that I have to get to top somewhere. See earlier it was focused, so whatever coming in between either it got demolished or I got demolished that was the approach and that precipitated lot of anger inside! Now not looking at it with that smaller perspective, looking at larger perspective is there any other way through which I can reach there, I would say, broadening of perspective.I am not compromising my target per say but I am trying to refined the route in such a way that in its destructive way.

D:      So do you think you have started knowing you real being inside haan.

P:      books that I used to read were more of guns and unknown identity and those, but now I read stuff like with more human touch kind of thing. Compassion is the one word I could say may be I feel            much more compassionate towards other people than earlier.

3^rd follow up (after 3 months)

D:      Since the last time that we met but since the beginning, since the first time we met just to recapitulate overall how are you in every aspect, you remember what you said?

P:      Much Better! Much Better! See I had a stomach issue, stomach issue is gone. I was feeling of great uneasiness because I believe that stomach would distend to whatever that has improved greatly, I was sentimental, emotional I was driven to tears may be on small things! I have improved overall to extent about 80% still those. I find huge improvement since the last time.

D:      How is all mental feeling which you describe to me, about maintaining and you remember?

P:      This punch that drive is still there but expression is tamed off to some extent, I mean earlier it used to be visible with somehow. Earlier I use to be aggressive in   meetings; I use to be vocal in my meetings. Now off late I have been more diplomatic kind off !I mean I am not losing cool over things and even if I do I am not conveying out to you that there is there some problem or something like that.

Follow up after 6 months

D:      So what this treatment has made a difference in you as a person.

P:      One the fear which I had within myself that something is wrong with the system, I find that fears to great extent have vanished and the anxiety which was there inside, there is no pain it has reduced drastically!

Secondly thing is if I was looking at particular situation or object with a perspective, I was not in a position to look at it with larger perspective, e.g. suppose I am   doing this in this my profit there but what happens to the other person! So you are not more of a single player, you are more of a how do I say team, team player no, you are more of a co-existence according to me.

P:      self-confidence has increase thirdly thing survival in group, I would in say in group in society, it is not alone me it is other’s also, these to a great extent has helped me, the way I looked at it.

D:      What do you mean by larger perspective?

P:      Sir before I use to tell you I could tell you my thought I have to do it, I ‘THE BIG’ ‘I’ was there to a great extent, I think the only thing is when you are looking at anything with an ‘I’, now I am able to look at other story also

P:      So what is good thing in these is, in our office cut throat is going on in every day to day affair. Now you have got many more friends you know, you are able to co-exist with lot of people. Lot of changes are there within I would say, if you ask me medically I cannot pinpoint it, these is how things are personally.

D:      So when you say larger perspective, what?

P:      I have become much more aware of what I was. Earlier that motive was narrow minded or selfish. It was self-centered kind. My work will be done and it will not have bad effect on other person, this is what I am trying to convey.

D:      What do you mean by ‘I’ has softened?

P:      I am working for many years on different ranks so ‘I’ becomes larger than you, the ego part I would say, ‘I’ is too big and what happens is that ‘I’ when starts getting challenged by people, then you start getting hate from inside, worry starts coming up, anxiety starts, I mean if you are able to communicate, convey it properly, work is also done.

Follow up after 8 months

D:      You said last time, I am watching as a third observer.

P:      Third Observer, sometime I laugh that you are reacting in such a way. Its great earlier you use to get involved, you get angry, further anger increases, more it increases. Now a days it doesn’t happen you are relaxed, automatically you are away, there are two people discussing and it’s fun you are able to laugh at yourself then. In last 4-5 months, I have not lost my temper at all

I am able to grasp myself that I am one personality, I am discussing something but I am in a position to get aloof from whole system, I am able to watch as a neutral person, the dialogue which is            going on between two person, I am able to analyze it at real time at equal as an independent personality.

I am not been prejudice towards me O.K, I am able to look at it as a third umpire or neutral person and in that I am able to find out in me, I shouldn’t have done this and that comes out     very effectively there itself correction is done, because I myself is there, I am able to, you know weigh your consequences. So no anger no frustration, no anxiety, and no negativity.

Applying the universal laws we not only understand the individualistic holistic centre of the individual, but even the Materia Medica, even the universality of the periodic table, each row, column, each element in the periodic table. Universal laws help in understanding the whole and also the part, which is nothing but integrated into the whole and beautifully completes the circle of the beginning to end to beginning.

 

Biography: Dr. Dinesh Chauhan practices Classical homoeopathy in Mumbai, India. Case Witnessing Process is a scientific and human-centric case taking approach developed by him over a decade of research and seeing patient after patient at Swasthya Homeopathic Healing. Distinguished as a lecturer in many countries, he has the ability to captivate listener’s attention as he masterfully makes homoeopathic theory come to life. He heads the non-profit ABJF foundation with his wife Dr. Urvi Chauhan where Indian Homoeopaths are taught free. He is the author of the books A Journey into the Human Core; A Wander with a Little Wonder - Child centric Case witnessing, and The Scientifically Intuitive Case Witnessing Process – A Journey of Three Steps.

Website: www.homeohome.com , www.casewitnessing.com

Email: This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it. , This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.